SES Software users have held an annual conference to provide input on software enhancements, review program updates, and provide a forum for users and SES researchers to make presentations on electrical safety, transmission line and substation grounding design, and improved methods for protecting equipment and pipelines against AC interference. Users had the opportunity to showcase their technical papers and companies, attend workshops, obtain certification, and acquire 25 Professional Development Hours. The conference is a unique opportunity for all CDEGS users to interact with others from many different backgrounds from all over the world, as well as the specialists from SES.
The 33rd Annual CDEGS Users' Group Conference took place in Portland, Maine, USA, from June 11 to 14, 2024.
The 2024 Users' Group Conference officers were:
Dennis Kastsianok (SR3 Engineering)
Chair
Andrea Helmig (SR3 Engineering)
Vice Chair
Chance Baker (Burns & McDonnell)
Secretary-Treasurer
Kurt Bell (Power Engineers)
Vice Secretary-Treasurer
TECHNIQUES TO REDUCE THE NUMBER OF SEGMENTS IN A COMPUTER SIMULATION MODEL
We present several methodologies to reduce the number of conductor segments in a computer simulation model.
As in any similar simplification processes, the objective is to reduce the size of the system as much as possible, while
maintaining the solution’s accuracy. Different reduction strategies applicable to electrically small and large grids
will be presented, quantified, and compared. The special cases of large photovoltaic generation plants will also be
presented and discussed.
This article shows how to embed the fault current split calculation into a MALZ grounding system model, based on
two initial FCDIST simulations, dispensing with the need to revisit FCDIST after modifications are made to the
grounding system model or soil structure. Both the theory, based on Thévenin equivalent circuits, and detailed
instructions are presented.
COMPUTING THE T-EQUIVALENT ZERO-SEQUENCE IMPEDANCES OF Y-Y-Δ AND AUTO-Y-Δ TRANSFORMERS FROM TEST DATA
For three-phase, three-winding transformers that have a tertiary delta winding, zero-sequence tests are typically
performed with the delta winding in place. Results from such tests are affected by the circulating currents formed
in the delta winding. To use the resulting impedances in a computer model based on the T-equivalent circuit, one
must convert such data into parameters suitable for simulation. In this article, formulae for such transformations
are derived from the typical zero-sequence tests setup vs. the desired zero-sequence tests setup. The methodology
is applicable to star-star-delta as well as auto-star-delta configurations.
Procedures to create circuit models in HIFREQ and calculate their sequence components are described. The
sequence components obtained with the provided methods can be used to validate the results from the
corresponding TRALIN model or data in manufacturer datasheets. Moreover, more complicated and realistic
circuit models can be created in HIFREQ, such as networks including metallic plates or other types of system
configurations that cannot be represented by the parallel conductors or cables used in TRALIN models. The
presented methods provide more flexibility to calculate sequence components for this kind of system.
ANALYSIS OF CORROSION EFFECTS DUE TO STRAY CURRENTS FROM DC ELECTRIFIED RAILWAYS
Yexu Li | Farid Paul Dawalibi | Stephane Franiatte | Maxime Daigle Carleen Cheng | Sinoheh Enayati | Francis Gougeon SafEngServices & technologies ltd.
Running rails used as a return conductor and grounded or ungrounded schemes have been widely adopted in DC
traction power systems. Ideally, all the current should return through the rails. But due to the resistances of tracks
and insulation deterioration between tracks and track slab, there will be a portion of the return traction current
that leaks from the intended path (i.e. running rails) called stray current. This stray current can cause serious
problems by accelerating the corrosion process of a buried pipeline and other metallic structures located near the
DC traction system.
This article describes and discusses investigations of typical physical models of the DC traction systems, including
medium-voltage direct current (MVDC) railway electrification system (RES) and DC light rail transit (DC-LRT).
Rail potentials and stray currents were calculated for different scenarios, accounting for dynamic, real-time
traction conditions. The corrosion trend of stray current is quantitatively calculated, and the corrosion rate of stray
current is evaluated. Furthermore, an impressed current cathodic protection (ICCP) system is designed, and its
effectiveness is verified considering the non-linear polarization process. The results show that CDEGS can
quantitatively calculate and predict the mass loss of buried metal caused by DC traction stray current corrosion,
and cost-effective CP design can be achieved.
A NOVEL ELECTROMAGNETIC DEVICE FOR REMOTE GROUNDING CONDUCTOR DETECTION AND DIAGNOSIS
François Grange | Houda Rehbi | Sébastien Journet | Farid Paul Dawalibi SES-EUROPE
The localization of grounding grid conductors is essential to diagnosing their status. In this work, a novel remote
electromagnetic device capable of locating and mapping grounding grid conductors is developed. The
electromagnetic field method is used, and the detection of the target conductors is obtained based on the responses
of the sensing coils contained on the developed device. This remote grounding conductor detection device can be a
good candidate for assessing the performance of grounding grid systems, including their integrity and boundaries.
BEST PRACTICES FOR BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE FACILITY EARTHING ANALYSIS
Lexi Turkenburg | Lucas Cook NEI Electric Power Engineering Inc neiengineering.com
Although battery energy storage system (BESS) facilities are still relatively new to the power
system industry, their integration into the resource mix continues to accelerate throughout North
America, as well as other parts of the world. While the electrical topology of utility-scale BESS
sites are similar to other inverter-based resources (IBRs), there are key differences in design
approaches to earthing analysis of the BESS yard compared to a solar or wind turbine site.
MODELING TUNNEL BORING UNDERNEATH AN EXISTING SUBSTATION
Donald del Rosario, P.E. Pacific Gas and Electric Company pge.com
Modeling a train tunnel boring underneath an existing substation can be performed using CDEGS MALZ software.
This article presents the high-level process of doing so and demonstrates available adjustments that can be made
to make the computations to work.
CALCULATIONS OF RESISTIVE POWER LOSSES IN METALLIC MATERIALS EXPOSED TO MAGNETIC FIELDS
This article discusses the calculations of resistive power losses in metallic materials exposed to magnetic fields,
using the HIFREQ module for simulations. Substation components such as steel plates and aluminum connectors
are studied by examining the impact of magnetic fields on induced currents and subsequent resistive power losses.
Validation of the simulation results is achieved through comparison with Ansys Maxwell software. It also includes
a practical case study on the optimal positioning of connectors to minimize magnetic interference. The findings
confirm the effectiveness of the HIFREQ module in assessing resistive power losses and show the importance of
precise mesh subdivision in enhancing the reliability of simulation results.
Accurate modeling of soil characteristics is fundamental to grounding system design, electromagnetic interference
(EMI) evaluation, and transient analysis in electric, pipeline, railway and several other public and private utilities.
While the horizontal multi-layer soil model remains the most widely used, a new modeling capability, vertical
multi-layer soil, is now available in the recently released version 20 of the HIFREQ computation module of the
MultiFields software package. This article highlights the value of this soil model in important scenarios for specific
use cases. For instance, in AC interference studies along long transmission line or pipeline corridors that traverse
varied geological formations, the use of a vertical multi-layer soil can serve as a first-order approximation. In cases
like these, with terrains that have distinct vertical stratifications, the vertical multilayer soil modeling yields the
most accurate results, outperforming the multi-region horizontal soil models available in CDEGS in some cases. It
also plays a key supporting role in EMI and AC interference analysis, particularly when structures are located near
vertical boundaries, where accurate modeling of abrupt changes in soil properties is critical. By integrating this
approach, engineers can enhance the accuracy of ground impedance predictions and EMI assessments, ensuring
model fidelity and cross-software consistency in complex geoelectrical environments. Detailed numerical results
of a practical case involving a three-layer vertical soil profile are presented, highlighting the real-world relevance
and technical value of this modeling technique.
HUMAN BODY MODEL MADE OF REALISTIC MATERIAL FOR SAFETY ASSESSMENT
This article presents the development of a human analog model composed of realistic, tissue-like materials that
closely replicate human anatomical structures. The model is designed to evaluate electrical safety across a wide
range of contact scenarios and environmental conditions. It has been calibrated to align with the outcomes defined
by the IEEE standard for electrical safety, ensuring accuracy under all conditions where the standard is applicable.
Notably, the model’s utility extends beyond the standard’s scope, enabling safety assessments in complex or
atypical situations—such as for submerged individuals or in environments with shallow soil layers—where
traditional standards fall short.
USING A FICTITIOUS MAIN PATH FOR MODELING FLEXIBILITY IN RIGHT-OF-WAY (ROWCAD)
This article introduces a strategy for defining a Fictitious Main Path in Right-of-Way (ROWCAD), freeing the main
path from being any single physical line. Instead, this path can be constructed from entirely new or combined
coordinates, enabling optimized region matching and improved circuit modeling in complex network
configurations. Through detailed explanation and visual illustrations, we outline the method's guiding principles
and demonstrate its practical benefits across multiple use cases.
This article presents a new signal type in SESTransient designed for modeling signals consisting of harmonics
directly from spectral input. Previously, it was possible to construct harmonic signals manually using multiple
HIFREQ runs and carefully scaled energizations, followed by signal synthesis in FFTSES. This method, while
theoretically rigorous, was time-consuming and prone to error. The new signal type simplifies this process by
allowing users to define harmonic spectra explicitly and apply them as time-domain excitation. The article reviews
the manual method and its theoretical basis, then details the implementation and use of the new feature, which
improves modeling accuracy and usability for harmonic studies in SESTransient.
WINDOWING AND PREPROCESSING TECHNIQUES FOR SESTRANSIENT STUDIES
This paper highlights the importance of windowing and preprocessing techniques in SESTransient workflows and
promotes greater awareness of spectral leakage phenomenon among practitioners. In doing so, it bridges a gap
between signal processing fundamentals and their practical application within the SESTransient analysis
framework.
Grounding systems are often overlooked when designing new facilities in the power industry. A grounding system
is generally designed using computer software estimates to determine compliance with applicable industry
standards. Is the constructed grounding system the same as the grounding system on the finalized drawings? How
are final grounding installations proven to perform as designed? This presentation will cover a case study of a
transmission grounding system that was designed using available and assumed data and then had a current
injection test completed at the “as-built” substation. The design and performance test data will be compared to
show how they intersect and demonstrate how a symbiotic relationship between modeling and testing can verify
installation performance while providing a more accurate baseline for future comparisons and modifications.
EXPLORING THE IMPACTS OF TRANSFER VOLTAGES ON NEARBY WATER MAINS
Significant substation upgrades were being made to a client’s substation including the addition of current limiting
reactors to reduce fault current magnitudes. Due to the substation expansion, a grounding analysis was needed to
design a touch and step voltage compliant grounding system. During this investigation three major water mains
were identified as being located between the focus substation and the neighboring transmission substation owned
by another entity. Concerns were raised about possible shock hazards on the water pipeline infrastructure during
a fault at either of the substations. This paper describes the overall project layout, concerns, analysis, and overall
mitigation approach. From start to finish this was a multiyear project involving three separate utilities with
significant coordination between the three.
AC INTERFERENCE ANALYSIS OF AN ELECTRICALLY CONTINUOUS GATHERING PIPELINE SYSTEM - A CASE STUDY
This case study addresses the unique challenges associated with an AC interference study for a 17-square-mile,
electrically continuous natural gas and liquids gathering system impacted by the installation of a new 525 kV high-voltage power line. The assessment employed SES SESCAD three-dimensional electromagnetic field software to
facilitate steady-state and ground fault analysis of both above-ground and below-ground pipelines, vertical
production wells, and above-ground facilities. The complex geometry of the gathering line colocation, deep
production well casings, and unknown isolation locations created a need for more rigorous field data gathering and
complex modeling compared to a typical pipeline AC interference study. Developing a detailed field data plan was
critical to ensure the computational model could accurately replicate the 124 interconnected pipelines and
associated facilities. SES tools were leveraged to more accurately simulate the uncoated, on-grade pipeline in
partial soil contact and to create artificial facilities with identical resistance to ground.